categoryMenu_new
 
  Home
  EXTRAORDINARY AH Teaching from Spiritual Hierarchy
  AbundantHope
  NEW READERS! Read Here First
  Supporting AH
  Leadership of AbundantHope
  Announcements
  Regional AH Sites
  Other Sites with AH material
  Contact Us
  Becoming A Messiah
  OUR PUBLIC FORUM IS OPEN TOO ALL
  Mission Ideas
  System Busting
  Cleric Letter/English
  Translations of Cleric Letter
  AH Member Writings
  Candace
  Ron
  Rosie
  Jess
  Brian's Poetry
  James
  Giuseppe
  Esteban
  Telepathic Messages
  Candace
  Jess Anthony
  Vince
  Leonette
  John
  Adam
  Bela
  Joyce
  Hazel
  Kibo
  Peter
  Rosie
  Johan
  Lucia
  Lucia G
  Rubens
  Shellee-Kim
  Ben
  Dorothea
  Solon
  Others
  Targeted Messages
  Hano
  Light Flower
  Changing The Face Of Religion
  - Phoenix Journals - PDF in German
  Candace on Religion
  Other Spiritual Pieces
  Gems from God Like Productions
  Spiritual Nuggets by the Masters
  Phoenix Journals
  Phoenix Journals - PDF
  Telepathic Messages PDF books
  Selections from the Urantia Book
  Illustrations For The Urantia Book
  CMGSN Pieces
  THE WAVE
  Environment/Science
  David Crayford and the ITC
 
  Health and Nutrition
  Podcasts, Radio Shows, Video by AH
  Political Information
  True US History
  Human/Animal Rights
  The Miracle That Is Me
  Education
  Resources
  911 Material
  Books - eBooks
  government email/phone #'s
  Self Reliance
  Video
  Websites
  Alternative News Sources
  Art and Music
  Foreign Sites
  Health and Healing
  Human/Animal Rights
  Scientific
  Spiritual
  Vegan Recipes
  Translated Material
  Dutch
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Jess
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Candace
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Anderen
  Artikelen/berichten
  French
  Canal Jess
  Par Candace
  Other Channels
  Articles
  German
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Candace)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Jess)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (div.)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Candace)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Jess)
  Spirituelle Schätze
  Italian
  Translations - Candace
  Translations - Jess
  Translations - Others
  Portuguese
  by Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Spanish
  Anfitriones Divinos
  Bitácoras Fénix
  Creadores-de-Alas (WingMakers/Lyricus)
  Escritos de Candace
  Escritos de Otros
  Monjoronsón
  Telemensajes de Candace
  Telemensajes de Jess Anthony
  Telemensajes de Otros
  Chinese
  By Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Korean Translations
  Hungarian Translations
  Swedish Translations

Search
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Health and Nutrition Last Updated: Mar 15, 2021 - 10:28:00 PM


The Great Pretender: Stanford psychology professor cherry-picked data in famous study of psychiatric institutions
By Susannah Cahalan
Nov 18, 2019 - 6:56:58 PM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page Share/Bookmark

https://www.sott.net/article/423906-The-Great-Pretender-Stanford-psychology-professor-cherry-picked-data-in-famous-study-of-psychiatric-institutions

02 Nov 2019

David Rosenhan

© Denver Post via Getty Images


Students loved professor David Rosenhan for his golden voice and charismatic teaching style, but his ability to embroider a story infected his research.Stanford psychology and law professor David Rosenhan could transfix an audience in a crowded lecture hall with just a few words.

"What is abnormality?" he would ask undergraduate students, his deep and resonant golden voice building and booming. "What are we here for? Some things will be black ... Others will be white. But be prepared for shades of gray."

Rosenhan would know. His own life, as I would later find out, was filled with shades of gray.

He wasn't particularly attractive - the word often used to describe him was "balding" - but there was something magnetic, even seductive, about him, especially in front of a crowd.

His students called it a gift, describing his ability to "rivet a group of two to three hundred students with dynamic lectures that are full of feeling and poetry." One student recalled how Rosenhan opened one of his lectures while sitting on a student's lap - as a way to test the class' reaction to abnormal behavior.

His research work was also groundbreaking. In 1973, Rosenhan published the paper "On Being Sane in Insane Places" in the prestigious journal Science, and it was a sensation. The study, in which eight healthy volunteers went undercover as "pseudopatients" in 12 psychiatric hospitals across the country, discovered harrowing conditions that led to national outrage. His findings helped expedite the widespread closure of psychiatric institutions across the country, changing mental health care in the US forever.

Fifty years later, I tried to find out how Rosenhan had convinced his subjects to go undercover as psychiatric patients and discovered a whole lot more.Yes, Rosenhan had charm. He had charisma. He had chutzpah to spare. And, as I eventually uncovered, he was also not what he appeared to be.


Comment: Sound familiar? Charming, highly charismatic and capable of inventing outrageous lies with no remorse - they're called psychopaths.


I stumbled across Rosenhan and his study six years ago while on a book tour for my memoir "Brain on Fire," which chronicled my experiences with a dangerous misdiagnosis, when doctors believed that my autoimmune disorder was a serious mental illness. After my talk, a psychologist and researcher suggested that I could be considered a "modern-day pseudopatient" from Rosenhan's famous study.

Reading the study for the first time that night in my hotel room, I was struck by its opening words: "If sanity and insanity exist, how shall we know them?" Psychiatry had been struggling throughout its history to answer this question, and Rosenhan's paper, with its rigorous data collection, exposed the deep limitations in our attempt to answer it.

Rosenhan's eight healthy pseudopatients allegedly each followed the same script to gain admittance to psychiatric hospitals around the country. They each told doctors that they heard voices that said, "Thud, empty, hollow." Based on this one symptom alone, the study claimed, all of the pseudopatients were diagnosed with a mental illness - mostly schizophrenia.

And once they were labeled with a mental illness, it became impossible to prove otherwise. All eight were kept hospitalized for an average of 19 days - with the longest staying an unimaginable 52. They each left "against medical advice," meaning the doctors believed that they were too sick to leave. A total of 2,100 pills - serious psychiatric drugs - reportedly were prescribed to these otherwise healthy individuals.

At the time, the collective American imagination was deeply suspicious of psychiatry and its institutions. It was the era of Ken Kesey's "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" and movies like "Shock Corridor" and "The Snake Pit." Rosenhan - who was both an insider who studied abnormal psychology, and an outsider who was a psychologist rather than a psychiatrist - was the perfect person to pull back the curtain on psychiatry's secrets.

His paper had an outsize impact and sparked further movements in the mental health world - helping to debunk Freudian psychoanalysis, medicalizing psychiatry and pushing for mental health patients' rights, to name just a few. His conclusions were "like a sword plunged into the heart of psychiatry," an article in the Journal of Nervous and Mental Diseases observed three decades later.

When I read his paper, I recognized my own experience with misdiagnosis in those nine pages. I saw the power of labels, the feeling of depersonalization as a psychiatric patient, the hopelessness.

I wanted to learn more about the study, about the participants who, at the urging of the charismatic Rosenhan, would put their lives on the line to volunteer for such a treacherous assignment.

So I was surprised to find that so little had been written about his study beyond the piece in Science. None of the pseudopatients had gone public and Rosenhan, sadly, had died in 2012. Instead, I started talking to the people who'd been closest to him during his life and career to try to understand the professor who had accomplished such a coup.

"He had a twinkle," Florence Keller, a close friend, recalled.

"If [a] party were dead, he would walk in and all of a sudden the party would come alive," his son Jack Rosenhan recounted.

"I think he always made people feel special," his research assistant Nancy Horn said.

Disappointed that I could never meet him myself, I was thrilled when Keller introduced me to a treasure trove of documents he had left behind - including many never before seen: his unpublished book, diary entries and reams of correspondence.

The first pseudopatient - "David Lurie" in his notes - was very clearly Rosenhan himself.

"It all started out as a dare," Rosenhan told a local newspaper. "I was teaching psychology at Swarthmore College, and my students were saying that the course was too conceptual and abstract. So I said, 'OK, if you really want to know what mental patients are like, become mental patients.' "

Soon after that, Rosenhan went undercover for nine days at Haverford State Hospital in Haverford, Pa., in February 1969. His diary and book describe a host of indignities: soiled bathrooms without doors, inedible food, sheer boredom and ennui, rank disregard by the staff and doctors. Rosenhan even witnessed an attendant sexually assault one of the more disturbed patients. The only time Rosenhan was truly "seen" as a human by the staff was when an attendant mistook him for a doctor.

The experience was harrowing. After nine days, he pushed for a release and made sure that his undergraduate students - who were planning to follow him as undercover patients into the hospital - would not be allowed to go. Colleagues described a shaken, changed man after his experience.

I dug deeper. If his own students were forbidden from pursuing the experiment after this dismaying event, who were the others who had willingly followed in Rosenhan's footsteps? Why did they put their mental health - even their lives - on the line for this experiment?

The further I explored, the greater my concerns. With the exception of one paper defending "On Being Sane in Insane Places," Rosenhan never again published any studies on psychiatric hospitalization, even though this subject made him an international success.

He had also landed a lucrative book deal and had even written eight chapters, well over a hundred pages of it. But then Rosenhan suddenly refused to turn over the manuscript. Seven years later, his publisher sued him to return his advance. Why would he have given up on the subject that made him famous?

I also started to uncover serious inconsistencies between the documents I had found and the paper Rosenhan published in Science. For example, Rosenhan's medical record during his undercover stay at Haverford found that he had not, as he had written in his published paper, only exhibited one symptom of "thud, empty, hollow." Instead, he had told doctors that he put a "copper pot" up to his ears to drown out the noises and that he had been suicidal. This was a far more severe - and legitimately concerning - description of his illness than he had portrayed in his paper.

Meanwhile, I looked for the seven other pseudopatients and spent the next months of my life chasing ghosts. I hunted down rumors, pursuing one dead end after the next. I even hired a private detective, who got no further than I had.

After years of searching, I found only one pseudopatient who participated in the study and whose experience matched that of Rosenhan: Bill Underwood, who'd been a Stanford graduate student at the time.

The only other participant I discovered, Harry Lando, had a vastly different take. Lando had summed up his 19-day hospitalization at the US Public Health Service Hospital in San Francisco in one word: "positive."

Even though he too was misdiagnosed with schizophrenia, Lando felt it was a healing environment that helped people get better.

"The hospital seemed to have a calming effect. Someone might come in agitated and then fairly quickly they would tend to calm down. It was a benign environment," Lando, now a psychology professor at the University of Minnesota, recalled in an interview.

But instead of incorporating Lando into the study, Rosenhan dropped him from it.

Lando felt it was pretty obvious what had happened, and I agree: His data - the overall positive experience of his hospitalization - didn't match Rosenhan's thesis that institutions are uncaring, ineffective and even harmful places, and so they were discarded.

"Rosenhan was interested in diagnosis, and that's fine, but you've got to respect and accept the data, even if the data are not supportive of your preconceptions," Lando told me.

Rosenhan, I began to realize, may have been the ultimate unreliable narrator. And I believe it's possible some of the other pseudopatients he mentioned in his study never existed at all.

As a result, I am now seriously questioning a study I had once admired and had originally planned to celebrate. In my new book "The Great Pretender" (Grand Central Publishing), out this week, I paint the picture of a brilliant but flawed psychologist who was likely also a fabulist.

It wasn't what I intended, and I feel conflicted about my findings. I have so enjoyed dropping into Rosenhan's world and getting to know his mind and his loved ones - but I have no doubt that his creation, one that touches all of our lives, is flimsy at best. And it's time for the world to see the study for what it really is.

It's not the first time a paper published by an esteemed journal has been called into serious question, or even exposed as an outright lie. There was Dutch social psychologist Diederik Stapel, once renowned for finding a correlation between filthier train platforms and racist views at an Utrecht station, who is now infamous for inventing data.

Philip Zimbardo, the architect of the famous prison study, which took place in Stanford's basement in 1971, has also come under fire. Zimbardo and his researchers recruited students and assigned them roles as "inmates" or "guards." Guards abused inmates; inmates reacted as real prisoners. A 2018 Medium piece tracked down the original participants in that study and exposed serious issues - including the fact that Zimbardo had coached the guards into behaving aggressively.



Psychologist Peter Gray told me that he sees the work of researchers such as Zimbardo and Rosenhan as prime examples of studies that "fit our biases ... There is a kind of desire to expose the problems of society but in the process cut corners or even make up data."

This may explain Rosenhan. He saw real problems in society: The country was warehousing very sick people in horror houses pretending to be hospitals, our diagnostic systems were flawed and psychiatrists in many ways had too much power - and very little substance. He saw how psychiatric labels degraded people and how doctors see patients through the prism of their mental illness. All of this was true. In many ways, it is still true.

But the problem is that scientific research needs to be sound. We cannot build progress on a rotten foundation.

In disregarding Lando's data and inventing other facts, Rosenhan missed an opportunity to create something three-dimensional, something a bit messier but more honest. Instead, he helped perpetuate a dangerous half-truth.

And today, what we have is a mental health crisis of epic proportions. Over 100,000 people with serious mental illnesses live on the streets, while we are chronically short of safe housing and hospital beds for the sickest among us.


Comment: Another example of good intentions gone wrong: Loss of psychiatric hospitals led to a mental health crisis in US


Had Rosenhan been more measured in his treatment of the hospitals, had he included Lando's data, there's a chance a different dialogue, less extreme in its certainty, would have emerged from his study, and maybe, just maybe, we'd be in a better place.

Susannah Cahalan is the author of "The Great Pretender" about famed psychology professor David Rosenhan, whom she discovered while on a book tour for her memoir, "Brain on Fire." The book chronicled her experiences with doctors who believed her autoimmune disorder was a serious mental illness.


Comment: Rosenhan is merely one in a long line of 'scientists-in-name-only' who have inflicted untold harm using suspect data and flawed analyses:




All writings by members of AbundantHope are copyrighted by
©2005-2021 AbundantHope - All rights reserved

Detailed explanation of AbundantHope's Copyrights are found here


Top of Page

Health and Nutrition
Latest Headlines
Majority Of Hospitalized Covid Patients In UK Only Tested Positive After Admission: Leaked NHS Data
How the Plague of Corruption Is Killing Mankind
Children in the Philippines Have Been Banned From Exiting Their Homes for 68 of the Last 70 Weeks
Governor Andrew Cuomo Says Unvaccinated Citizens Will Be ‘Put' In Vehicles And Driven To Vaccination Sites
General Dismisses Troop Suicide Spike While Pushing For COVID Vaccination
CDC Declares PCR Tests Must Go Immediately After George Soros, Bill Gates Buy COVID-19 Test Manufacturer
World's Food Supplies In Jeopardy Amid Climate Disasters
'Health Freedom' Is The Hottest Global Political Issue, And Our World Will Never Be The Same After This
The Other Side of the COVID Vaccination Argument, Video
The Big Lie and The Fear Campaign: The Delta Variant is “1,000 Times More Transmissible Than The Original Virus”
With Narrative Established, CDC Announces Withdrawal of Rapid Response COVID Test to Belatedly Stop Diagnosing Influenza as SARS-COV-2?
47 Studies Confirm Ineffectiveness of Masks For Covid and 32 More Confirm Their Negative Health Effects
Mask flip-flop? CDC ‘actively’ Considering Face Cover Advisory for Vaccinated Americans, According to Fauci
A covid-19 crop circle
Why Are The NHS Putting Out A £3.2 Billion Contract for Blood Clot Treatment?
CHD Files 10th Lawsuit Against Merck, Alleging Gardasil HPV Vaccine Caused Serious Injuries
Majority of Physicians Decline COVID Shots, according to Survey
UK to Launch Daily COVID Tests in Food Sector to Tackle 'pingdemic'
AstraZeneca Vaccines Being Dumped Over 'lack of patients', GP in Australia Reports
Report: German Catholic Church Continues Hemorrhaging Members