categoryMenu_new
 
  Home
  EXTRAORDINARY AH Teaching from Spiritual Hierarchy
  AbundantHope
  NEW READERS! Read Here First
  Supporting AH
  Leadership of AbundantHope
  Announcements
  Regional AH Sites
  Other Sites with AH material
  Contact Us
  Becoming A Messiah
  OUR PUBLIC FORUM IS OPEN TOO ALL
  Mission Ideas
  System Busting
  Cleric Letter/English
  Translations of Cleric Letter
  AH Member Writings
  Candace
  Ron
  Rosie
  Jess
  Brian's Poetry
  James
  Giuseppe
  Esteban
  Telepathic Messages
  Candace
  Jess Anthony
  Vince
  Leonette
  John
  Adam
  Bela
  Joyce
  Hazel
  Kibo
  Peter
  Rosie
  Johan
  Lucia
  Lucia G
  Rubens
  Shellee-Kim
  Ben
  Dorothea
  Solon
  Others
  Targeted Messages
  Hano
  Light Flower
  Changing The Face Of Religion
  - Phoenix Journals - PDF in German
  Candace on Religion
  Other Spiritual Pieces
  Spiritual Nuggets by the Masters
  Phoenix Journals
  Phoenix Journals - PDF
  Telepathic Messages PDF books
  Selections from the Urantia Book
  Illustrations For The Urantia Book
  CMGSN Pieces
  THE WAVE
  Environment/Science
  David Crayford and the ITC
  Health and Nutrition
  Podcasts, Radio Shows, Video by AH
  Political Information
  True US History
  Human/Animal Rights
  The Miracle That Is Me
  Education
  Resources
  911 Material
  Books - eBooks
  government email/phone #'s
  Self Reliance
  Video
  Websites
  Alternative News Sources
  Art and Music
  Foreign Sites
  Health and Healing
  Human/Animal Rights
  Scientific
  Spiritual
  Vegan Recipes
  Translated Material
  Dutch
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Jess
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Candace
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Anderen
  Artikelen/berichten
  French
  Canal Jess
  Par Candace
  Other Channels
  Articles
  German
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Candace)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Jess)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (div.)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Candace)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Jess)
  Spirituelle Schätze
  Italian
  Translations - Candace
  Translations - Jess
  Translations - Others
  Portuguese
  by Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Spanish
  Anfitriones Divinos
  Bitácoras Fénix
  Creadores-de-Alas (WingMakers/Lyricus)
  Escritos de Candace
  Escritos de Otros
  Monjoronsón
  Telemensajes de Candace
  Telemensajes de Jess Anthony
  Telemensajes de Otros
  Chinese
  By Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Korean Translations
  Hungarian Translations
  Swedish Translations

Search
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Political Information : True US History Last Updated: Aug 8, 2019 - 8:21:57 AM


Mandatory National Service: A Bad Idea That Won’t Die
By Doug Bandow
Aug 8, 2019 - 4:37:55 AM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page Share/Bookmark

https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/mandatory-national-service-a-bad-idea-that-wont-die/


Credit: Ethan Miller/Getty Images

Another presidential election, another proposal for mandatory national "service." This time, two Democratic candidates hope to turbocharge their otherwise dubious electoral prospects by proposing to draft all young people to spend a year or two working for Washington's political elite.

That's not how they put it, of course. But that is what the national service movement is about.

Service, real service to real people, is baked into Americans' DNA. Alexis de Tocqueville, the great French classical liberal, cited civic activism as one of the new republic's distinguishing characteristics in his famous Democracy in America. He wrote: "I have seen Americans making great and sincere sacrifices for the key common good, and a hundred times I have noticed that, when needs be, they almost always gave each other faithful support." The resulting vibrant civil society was very different from the enervating monarchies and aristocracies that still dominated Europe. This commitment to service permeated the nation-transforming people, creating institutions, and strengthening America.

But some commentators and politicians view private action as inadequate. Instead, they believe, "service" should be organized, planned, and managed by the state. The fount of modern thought on national service remains Looking Backward, the 1888 publication of lawyer and journalist Edward Bellamy, which envisioned compulsory employment for men and women between the ages of 21 and 45.

A couple decades later, philosopher William James issued an essay, "The Moral Equivalent of War." In it, he argued that "the martial virtues, although originally gained by the race through war, are absolute and permanent human goods," and that national service provided a method for instilling those values during peacetime. He wrote: "Our gilded youths would be drafted off to get the childishness knocked out of them, and to come back into society with healthier sympathies and soberer ideas."

Today his essay is almost entirely forgotten, except for the title. But a host of philosophers, policy analysts, and politicians proffer their own very different proposals for "the moral equivalent of war." These plans rarely reflect a shared consensus of the national or public interest. More often, they involve blatant social engineering for ideological ends. For instance, sociologist Margaret Mead advocated a universal program that "would replace for girls, even more than for boys, marriage as the route away from the parental home."

Compulsion was essential to such proposals. In 1979, the Committee for the Study of National Service declared:

International comparisons also fire some American imaginations. Millions of young people serve social needs in China as a routine part of growing up, many [are] commanded to leave the crowded cities and to assist in the countryside.  Castro fought illiteracy and mosquitoes in Cuba with units of youth. Interesting combinations of education, work, and service to society are a part of the experience of youth in Israel, Jamaica, Nigeria, Tanzania, and other nations.  The civic spirit being imbued in youth elsewhere in the world leaves some Americans wondering and worrying about Saturday-night-fever, unemployment, the new narcissism, and other afflictions of American youth.

Admittedly, seeing Mao's Red Guards as a model for America appears dated at best. But current national service advocates similarly seek to transform society. They envision their program providing job training and employment, encouraging social equality, promoting tolerance and civic-mindedness, expanding access to college, engendering patriotism, and addressing ubiquitous "unmet social needs." The idea sounds great. But in practice it is dangerous nonsense.

First to join the ranks of national service advocates was South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg, who complained about America's lack of "social cohesion." What to do? Why, force everyone to work together, of course! Voila, "social cohesion"! In his defense, Buttigieg was just ambiguous enough to allow himself to wriggle out of a political tight spot. He explained on MSNBC: "One thing we could do that would change that [inadequate social cohesion] would be to make it, if not legally obligatory, but certainly a social norm that anybody, after they're 18, spends a year in national service."

The problem is that a lack of compulsion ensures that Buttigieg's plan will fail. There will always be 18-year-olds who will resist even a purported "social norm." Yet for national service advocates, such resisters are precisely those most in need of civilizing "service," meaning political projects mandated by the social engineers in Washington. Those suffering from "Saturday night fever, unemployment, the new narcissism, and other afflictions of American youth" don't realize that they are sick and therefore must be forcibly cured.

John Delaney would unashamedly drop any ambiguity. Polling at less than 1 percent makes presidential candidates say the damnedest things. He tweeted: "It's time to bring the country together, to restore our sense of shared purpose and rebuild a common and inclusive national destiny. That's why we need mandatory national service." Every 18-year-old would have to work for Uncle Sam for at least a year, "no exceptions."

It is a remarkably dumb idea. First, there's the constitutional problem-the 13th Amendment clearly proscribes "involuntary servitude," the foundation of Delaney's program. Moreover, as worthy as it might be to encourage others to "begin their adult lives serving their country and working alongside people from different backgrounds," that is a bad reason for what amounts to enslavement. National service requires punishing people-presumably by arresting and jailing them-for resisting the state's social engineering.

Under Delaney's plan, conscripts, conveniently excluding people his or Buttigieg's age, would choose between serving in the military, "a new expanded Community Service program," "a new National infrastructure Apprenticeship program," and "a newly created Climate Corps." Conceptually, there's nothing particularly new in his proposal. But subjugating people to provide cheap labor for politically inspired projects is bad both in principle and practice.

First, the military doesn't want conscripts or short-termers. The armed services learned during the Vietnam War that those who don't want to be there tend to develop discipline problems, have little interest in training and education, refuse to take greater responsibility, and won't re-up and populate a career NCO corps. Moreover, one year of military service is a spectacular waste: just as someone gets trained, he or she leaves.

Second, "community service"-cleaning hospital bedpans, shelving library books, and whatever else moves interest groups and legislators-is valuable but not national, and moral but only if not coerced. There is no such thing as compulsory compassion. It is hard to think of a worse abuse of government power than to arrest and jail someone for not showing up to "tutor disadvantaged children," one of Delaney's approved projects.

Third, "infrastructure apprenticeship," meaning cleaning up parks and improving federal buildings, is not "service" in any meaningful sense. The government can easily hire workers for such jobs. Coercing people to perform such tasks isn't going to morally uplift anyone.

Fourth, the "Climate Corps" is more of the same, namely assisting "in clean energy projects, including solar installation, improving building efficiency, developing community gardens, and increasing awareness about sustainable practices." Apparently running for president has left Delaney almost completely disconnected from American life. Companies send people door-to-door to sell products that cut energy use. Firms fiercely compete to install solar panels on private homes and in commercial operations. People freely create community gardens in their neighborhoods without the assistance of federal conscripts. And there's plenty of lobbying for "sustainable practices." You don't need to threaten to arrest people to force them into the PR business.

Perhaps the biggest problem with national service is that neither Delaney nor Buttigieg nor anyone else seems to understand the opportunity costs. That is, drafting people to plant gardens, pick up trash, smile at hospital patients, manage food kitchens, and improve federal facilities costs whatever else the draftees would otherwise be doing: completing their education, helping family members in need, contributing to their communities in their own way, preparing for economically and socially valuable careers, and otherwise using their skills to better meet human needs. Having politicians assign people to an arbitrary mix of tasks, virtually none of which are vital in any sense, is guaranteed to be a grand waste of money, time, and talent.

Delaney wants to "restore our sense of shared purpose and a common and inclusive national destiny." That's a wonderful objective with which most people would agree. But corralling millions into his pet programs and jailing recalcitrant 18-year-olds who don't share his vision is no answer to anything. Such a program-with older men and women safely beyond its reach, free to blame young people for America's problems-would breed cynicism and hostility, not "service and patriotism."

America faces serious challenges. But most of them have no political solution. "We need big transformational change to stop America from dividing any further," argues Delaney. Then let him persuade his fellow citizens to voluntarily join him in making that transformational change. Americans need more service, not national "service."

[Colour fonts and bolding added.].

Doug Bandow is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute. He is a former special assistant to President Ronald Reagan and the author of several books, including The Politics of Plunder: Misgovernment in Washington.




All writings by members of AbundantHope are copyrighted by
©2005-2019 AbundantHope - All rights reserved

Detailed explanation of AbundantHope's Copyrights are found here


Top of Page

True US History
Latest Headlines
Documentary — Nebraska Retiree Uses Earth’s Heat to Grow Oranges in Snow
0:00 / 37:22 SerialBrain2: Dorian: The Lo Shu Grid and Alabama Mystery Solved. PART 2
Trump Comes Under Savage Attack By Crazed Judges Who Know Their Leftist End Is Near
Dr. John Dee: Occultist Behind the British Empire and Judaic New World Order
A Morning in Afghanistan
U.S. Debt Could Be 2,000% Of GDP: A $400 Trillion Nightmare
The Bill Of Rights Turns 230, And What Do We Have To Show For It ? Nothing Good
I Used to Think Strippers Who Drug & Rob Men were scum. Turns Out they are ‘empowered feminists’
SICK: Remains Of Over 2,000 Fetuses Found In Home Of Deceased Illinois Abortion Doctor
I’m a Feminist Who Was Purged by the Trans Left
World Braces For Bloodbath Holocaust As “October Revolution” Forces Grow In China
Bilateral Betrayal: The Free Trade Route to Globalism
John Bolton’s Resignation Letter is a Major Olive Branch to Both North And South Korea
Why Gen-Z'ers And Millennials Support Socialism
The National Debt Is Now More than Ten Times Annual Tax Receipts
SerialBrain2: The Explosive Message Trump Coded in his speech on Independence Day
SerialBrain2: Trump's Historic Visit to the UK: Winning, winning, winning
NBC News Wants You to Know That Heterosexuality 'Is The Bedrock of Global Oppression'
Unintended Nuclear War Warning Issued—Whose First Victims Of Said Should Be Climate Crazies
120 Million Workers Need To Be Reskilled Due To AI, Says IBM Study