categoryMenu_new
 
  Home
  EXTRAORDINARY AH Teaching from Spiritual Hierarchy
  AbundantHope
  NEW READERS! Read Here First
  Supporting AH
  Leadership of AbundantHope
  Announcements
  Regional AH Sites
  Other Sites with AH material
  Contact Us
  Becoming A Messiah
  OUR PUBLIC FORUM IS OPEN TOO ALL
  Mission Ideas
  System Busting
  Cleric Letter/English
  Translations of Cleric Letter
  AH Member Writings
  Candace
  Ron
  Rosie
  Jess
  Brian's Poetry
  James
  Giuseppe
  Esteban
  Telepathic Messages
  Candace
  Jess Anthony
  Vince
  Leonette
  John
  Adam
  Bela
  Joyce
  Hazel
  Kibo
  Peter
  Rosie
  Johan
  Lucia
  Lucia G
  Rubens
  Shellee-Kim
  Ben
  Dorothea
  Solon
  Others
  Targeted Messages
  Hano
  Light Flower
  Changing The Face Of Religion
  - Phoenix Journals - PDF in German
  Candace on Religion
  Other Spiritual Pieces
  Gems from God Like Productions
  Spiritual Nuggets by the Masters
  Phoenix Journals
  Phoenix Journals - PDF
  Telepathic Messages PDF books
  Selections from the Urantia Book
  Illustrations For The Urantia Book
  CMGSN Pieces
  THE WAVE
  Environment/Science
  David Crayford and the ITC
  Health and Nutrition
  Podcasts, Radio Shows, Video by AH
 
  Political Information
  True US History
  Human/Animal Rights
  The Miracle That Is Me
  Education
  Resources
  911 Material
  Books - eBooks
  government email/phone #'s
  Self Reliance
  Video
  Websites
  Alternative News Sources
  Art and Music
  Foreign Sites
  Health and Healing
  Human/Animal Rights
  Scientific
  Spiritual
  Vegan Recipes
  Translated Material
  Dutch
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Jess
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Candace
  Gekanaliseerde berichten Anderen
  Artikelen/berichten
  French
  Canal Jess
  Par Candace
  Other Channels
  Articles
  German
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Candace)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (Jess)
  Telepathische Nachrichten (div.)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Candace)
  AH Mitgliederbeiträge (Jess)
  Spirituelle Schätze
  Italian
  Translations - Candace
  Translations - Jess
  Translations - Others
  Portuguese
  by Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Spanish
  Anfitriones Divinos
  Bitácoras Fénix
  Creadores-de-Alas (WingMakers/Lyricus)
  Escritos de Candace
  Escritos de Otros
  Monjoronsón
  Telemensajes de Candace
  Telemensajes de Jess Anthony
  Telemensajes de Otros
  Chinese
  By Candace
  By Jess
  By Others
  Korean Translations
  Hungarian Translations
  Swedish Translations

Search
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Political Information Last Updated: Mar 28, 2022 - 12:08:15 PM


State-Level Secession Isn't Enough. The States Themselves Must be Radically Decentralized.
By Ryan McMaken with comments by Ron
Dec 10, 2021 - 6:40:37 PM

Email this article
 Printer friendly page Share/Bookmark

https://mises.org/wire/state-level-secession-isnt-enough-states-themselves-must-be-radically-decentralized


  • stateflags

 

Florida governor Ron DeSantis last month signed new legislation largely banning the use of vaccine mandates by either private entities or local governments. The new legislation also reinforces the DeSantis administration's overall efforts to prevent local governments from imposing mask mandates as well. Most notably, the administration has intervened to prevent school districts from imposing mandates.

This approach has predictably raised opposition. Generally, opponents of DeSantis's efforts at preempting local mandates have claimed that local governments ought to exercise some degree of independence from state policies.

When pressed on this issue at a press conference last month, DeSantis responded with a philosophical statement suggesting that the prerogatives of state governments ought to trump all other levels of government. Specifically, when asked why he was willing to impose state mandates on local governments-i.e., "violating the tenet of home rule"-DeSantis responded:

It's the United States of America, not the United school boards or county commissions of America. So the states are the primary vehicles to protect people's freedoms, their health, their safety, their welfare in our constitutional system.

He goes on to emphasize that local governments must be at the mercy of his state-level administration because local governments "don't have the right to do wrong." What is "wrong," of course, is to be decided by state-level politicians. This response strongly implies that DeSantis is of the opinion Florida-and apparently all the other states as well-are to function as unitary states. That is, his position appears to be that decentralized power is appropriate in relations between state governments and the federal governments-but has no role in the relationship between state governments and local governments.

Now, I view DeSantis as a politician who has generally done more good than harm, but is DeSantis right in this case? This is an important question that extends far beyond Florida's current debate over vaccine mandates.

Rather, this is a question that must be answered by any of us who push for political decentralization, whether through radically greater local autonomy or outright secession.

Unitary States versus Confederations

Essentially, the question-at least for Americans-comes down to whether or not radical decentralization applies only to relations between state governments and the federal government. If this applies only to state-federal relations, then decentralization apparently ought to stop at state borders. Thus, were there to be formal or de facto secession of a state in the future, then that state would thereafter function as a sovereign unitary state. Current examples of unitary states include France and Perú, in which the central government exercises broad and supreme power over any administrative subdivisions such as municipalities, counties, or provinces. Moreover, these local entities are creatures of the central government in that the central government governs them directly and can even abolish local governments without local consent.

Most countries in the world employ unitary governments. Moreover, the member states of the US themselves are currently unitary in nature. Municipalities and counties are creations of state law, and city and county governments can be created or abolished by acts of the state legislature. In some states, local governments enjoy some degree of autonomy through "home rule" provisions or statutes, but even in these cases, political power lies lopsidedly with the state government.

This is in contrast with the state-federal relationship in the US. Although the US states' power relative to the federal government has been thoroughly weakened in recent decades, it is still clear that the US government must frequently rely on financial incentives to get what they want from state governments, rather than imposing policies directly. Indeed, the covid crisis has highlighted the limits of federal powers within states in that-unlike in unitary states-the national government clearly never had had the legal power to impose nationwide "lockdowns."

On the other hand, because of the states' unitary structures, state governors have wielded immense power over municipal and county governments, imposing lockdowns, mask mandates, and more.

So the question remains: When US member states begin to obtain greater autonomy from the US federal government-which is inevitable either in the near future or the more distant future-will this simply lead to the creation of new unitary states exercising centralized political power over their own populations?

It would seem that any principled defense of decentralization must lead to calls for decentralization at the state level as well.

After all, to support a de facto or de jure independent and unitary state in say, Florida, would be simply to embrace the European model. Unitary sovereign states like Italy and Portugal govern directly from the national capitol without any chance of meaningful opposition from effectively sovereign regional governments.

Moreover, elections in one of these new unitary American regimes would become exactly what defenders of the electoral college have sought to avoid: statewide elections would-and presently do-reflect nothing more than majoritarianism, with the executive chosen based on the principle of winning 50 percent of the votes plus one. There would be no mechanism to balance regional political realities as the electoral college does with presidential elections now.

How to Turn US States into Confederations

If decentralization is something we take seriously-and not just a temporary ploy to get more autonomy for certain state governments-then state governments themselves must be limited by local autonomy.

Specifically, governance in these places must be subjected to tools that protect local autonomy. These tools include double majorities, local vetoes, and political representation not based on population size.

For example, let's look at a state like Colorado. Were the state to become an independent unitary state, the Denver metro area would exercise almost untrammeled power over the rest of the state. The western half of the state and the metro areas outside of Denver would be at the mercy of Denver-area voters. This, of course, is currently the situation in terms of statewide policy.

The answer to this could be found in giving metropolitan areas outside Denver a way to veto statewide policies that benefit only one or two regions of the state at the expense of everyone else. For example, a system of double majorities. This would mean that significant legislative changes would need to be approved by both a majority of the voters overall and also by a majority of voters in a majority of regional governments. (This system is presently used in Switzerland.) Similarly, different regions of the state would need to be given equal votes within a legislative body. That way each region of the state would be on equal footing regardless of each region's population. This would prevent the highly populated regions from riding roughshod over more rural regions. Moreover, supermajorities in the style of the old Articles of Confederation ought to be required.

Without measures such as these, these unitary governments would be governed on no principle other than rank majoritarianism.

But perhaps most importantly of all, it must be explicit that the state's municipalities or regional governments can legally secede. Without this guarantee, we'd simply be looking at an eventual repeat of what we see now in the United States: an entrenched ruling class at the national capital exercising outsized power to force policy on all regions of the nation regardless of local values, laws, or preferences.

So, DeSantis's view that state governments are necessarily the "primary vehicles" through which policy ought to be made is a dangerous view. It appears to presuppose that there is something magical about the state level of government and that no further decentralization of power is necessary.

DeSantis is, of course, correct that federal attempts to impose national covid mandates are dangerous and illegitimate. But he is wrong that decentralization is necessary only in limiting federal power. The danger of state-level power is especially present for larger states like Florida, California, New York and Texas. These states have populations the size of medium-sized European countries, and thus already consolidate far too much power into a small handful of unitary regimes. We could contrast states like Texas, for example-with 25 million people governed under a unitary regime-with a decentralized confederation like Switzerland, with 8 million people spread over twenty-six mostly self-governing cantons. Most of these cantons have populations of less than 1 million. It might strike some secessionists as fine to centralize political power in Sacramento or Austin or Tallahassee so long as the these polities have escaped the federal boot. But this scheme will only set up an eventual repeat of the sorts of federal abuses we see today.

[Ron: This author correctly identifies the need for genuine socio-political autonomy exercisable by ALL communities regardless of their size. Arguably organically organised communities should have the sovereign freedom to determine their own acceptable lifestyles and community policies subject only to their managers not being able to exercise dictatorial powers seriously impinging upon the physical, psychological or spiritual welfare of their members. Under Quantum governance arrangements that will be implemented during Christ Michael's Millennial Reign such freedom and oversight thereof will be implemented. An obvious restraint upon excessively negative socio-political tendencies in local community governance will no doubt be the ability of individuals and families to move to other communities deemed to be more amenable to their ideas and needs. But rest assured that seriously anti-spiritual and anti-social policies will be actively discouraged.]

[Some colour fonts, bolding and comments in square brackets added.].

 

Author:

Contact Ryan McMaken

Ryan McMaken is a senior editor at the Mises Institute. Send him your article submissions for the Mises Wire and Power and Market, but read article guidelines first.




All writings by members of AbundantHope are copyrighted by
©2005-2022 AbundantHope - All rights reserved

Detailed explanation of AbundantHope's Copyrights are found here


Top of Page

Political Information
Latest Headlines
AJ DePriest Uncovers The Enormous Covid Bribes
Israel Stunned by Ukrainian neo-Nazis
Exodus: Jews Once Again Forced into Exile from Beloved Odessa
World Economic Controlled Demolition
Sitrep: UNSC On Biolabs In The Ukraine + Russia Transcript
Lebanon Busts Mossad Spy Ring
George Soros: United States, European Union Must Remove Putin And Xi From Power ‘Before They Can Destroy Our Civilization’
Tucker Carlson Outlines Biden Strategy to Blame Russia for Outcomes of White House Economic Policy
New York Times Reporter Privately Admits Jan. 6 Riot Exaggerated, Disorganized, FBI Informants Involved
Democrat Spending Bill Contains 'Serious Expansion of Federal Gun Control': Gun Rights Group
Fired ER Doctor Tells RFK, Jr. ‘We Just Bowed Down’ Instead of Practicing Science
Here’s How The Freedom Convoy Changed Canada For The Better
Russian MoD: Joint Coordination Headquarters for Humanitarian Response in Ukraine
US Tried To Fund Bio labs In Ukraine As Early As 2005, records show
History Rhyming, Biden Administration Constructs Familiar War Plan Using Qatar as Long-Term Mechanism to Fund Protracted War in Ukraine
Andrei Martyanov Report
W.H.O. Scolds Pandemic Disbelievers: ‘We Warned You’ About Coronavirus
Congress Just Gave Itself A 21 Percent Pay Raise With Pork-Packed Omnibus Bill While Surging Gas Prices, Inflation Hurt Americans
War or Peace: Uncle Sam's Dirty Role In The Ukraine Crisis
White House Briefing Tik Tok Battalion To Advance NATO War Effort in Ukraine