Patriotism, Law, and Allegiance
By James Rothenburg
Jul 22, 2019 - 4:32:42 AM
patriotism (noun): love for or devotion to one's country
- Merriam-Webster -
Let's go a little further with this and break it down.
1: a distinctive doctrine, cause, or theory
2: an oppressive and especially discriminatory attitude or belief
- Merriam-Webster -
July 19, 2019 "Information Clearing House" - This opens things up - as a practice, who uses it, why and how is it used, and what are the ramifications of its use ?
Patriotic slogans, closer to shibboleths (...a word or saying used by adherents of a party, sect, or belief and usually regarded by others as empty of real meaning) such as, freedom isn't free, support the troops, honor our veterans, and God bless America, rely on a certain set of assumptions. Namely, that the state is benevolent, that it is moral, and that it acts as a whole to represent the goodwill and common interests of ordinary people.
The purpose of a marketing slogan is to create, in the target host, a suspension of the critical thought process. Its success as a strategy is complete when the host is unable or unwilling to seek an alternative. The tethering of the host to the sloganeer presents an imbalance of power, creating a vulnerability.
Patriotic sloganeering makes the citizen into a host, tethered to the state. When the citizen is sufficiently prepared through propaganda, the state has enormous leverage.
The dissident view on patriotism is that the state exploits the goodwill of its citizens into a double cross, rallying them into battle and support for war and vilification of whistleblowers and refuseniks while concealing its true purposes. This is beyond politics and generalizes to all states. States are, by degree, adversaries to the people in them. Big Brother is not a relative.
The universe works well as a metaphor for the state, a cold amoral entirety with a few warm spots here and there. The warm spots are necessary to appeal to the benevolent and altruistic side of humankind, without which the state as a ruling body would lose legitimacy. The job of the state is to keep the double cross operative by throwing in those exploitable warm spots amidst the cold amorality.
So goes the step of the capitalist, imperialist state baiting its young men and women to fight continuous war, prepared to sacrifice them while hiding behind the figurative skirts of "support" and "honor", and for those not paying the ultimate price in "freedom isn't free", thanking them for their service with 10% off.
Another shibboleth: Nobody is above the law
(Aside) Some laws are beneath all of us
Used to keep ordinary people from breaking the law under the pretense that all are subject to it. We're all in the same boat. The "law" is presented as a rigid body when in practice it is infinitely flexible. Since this flexibility is everywhere evident, for instance, some people clearly being over and beyond the law, there's nothing left for the state to do but lock up small people as continuous examples.
We can derive a general principle here:
The higher your station, the more you get away with. The lower your station, the less you get away with.
In this case, station is not only associated with wealth and social standing. The police and the military enjoy special status as agents of the state, as are those that act in other capacities as agents.
The special principle is:
The higher your value to the state, the more you get away with. The lower your value to the state, the less you get away with.
The expression, "we are a nation of laws", is low on content because what arrangement of society has ever been without them, even transmitted orally? The continual harping about this is more an indication of its disproof in much the same way as privacy promises were unnecessary when it existed.
We pledge allegiance to the flag for two reasons. So we remain that way, and so that we can be prosecuted when we don't. What is supposed to happen when the republic is not allegiant to its people ? The answer lies in our history.
James Rothenberg - firstname.lastname@example.org
[Colour fonts and bolding added.].
writings by members of AbundantHope are copyrighted by
AbundantHope - All rights reserved